Direction: Laura Parmet
Country: USA
The Starling Girl focuses on the negative impact of fanatic religious communities on young women's lives who are still searching for an identity. The drama, written and directed by debutant Laura Parmet, stars Australian-born actress Eliza Scanlen (Babyteeth, 2019), who, strong in her role, oscillates between uncontrollable desire and intense guilt.
In an ultra-conservative Christian small-town in Kentucky, the 17-year old Jem Starling (Scanlen) slowly awakes to sexuality and love when the local pastor’s elder son, Owen Taylor (Lewis Pullman), 28, returns from Puerto Rico. But Owen, a youth pastor himself, is married, and it’s his tedious brother, Ben (Austin Abrams), who asks her family permission to court her (a community tradition), with a clear intention to marry her in the future.
Although the film seems more likable than incisive or original, the patchy romance at the center is not stale. There’s also family problems, oodles of hypocrisy and public humiliation, while the slowness of the staging is commensurate with the labor of a story that overwhelms. But, in the end, does the film reach the depth expected? Just about. Disregarding the flat, unsatisfying ending, there are a few disturbing and dramatic moments of quiet power.
The themes, emphasizing the clash between feelings and values, will resonate with free spirited individuals as much as it will upset fanatical religious devotees.
