Anora (2024)

Direction: Sean Baker
Country: USA 

With his bittersweet worldview and keen sense of the ridiculous, Sean Baker (Tangerine, 2015; The Florida Project, 2017) delivers a jubilant if cruel indie comedy with Anora, his eighth feature film. A romantic tragicomedy that defies standard conventions, the film centers on Ani (Mikey Madison), a 23-year-old sex worker in New York whose life takes an unexpected turn when she marries Ivan Zhakharov (Mark Eydelshteyn), the spoiled son of a Russian oligarch.

This zany nuptial odyssey masterfully balances hysterical and heartfelt tones, weaving together themes of love, fury, laughter, and tears. Baker crafts anarchic, tension-filled situations that satirize unchecked capitalism and immature love, prompting reflection on two disparate souls seemingly escaping their respective prisons. The open-ended staging challenges its actors, who excel amidst the chaos, as the narrative seamlessly shifts between humor and heartache. The result is a dazzlingly paced love story driven by the electric chemistry between Madison and Eydelshteyn. 

Baker’s risk-taking approach and compelling writing are rewarded with neat images, a frenetic pace, and outstanding performances. The director films more statically than ever before, unafraid to take some time on certain scenes to make his social satire closer to reality. Despite its measured approach, monotony never creeps in, as Anora thrives on its originality and compelling characters who continuously evolve. 

With youthful ardor, audacious storytelling, and interpretive depth, the Palme D’Or winner Anora reaffirms Baker as a standout voice in American independent cinema. It’s a thought-provoking, wildly entertaining work that leaves a lasting impression.

Maria (2024)

Direction: Pablo Larraín
Country: USA / Italy / Germany

With Maria, which depicts the final week in the life of legendary American-born Greek opera singer Maria Callas, Chilean director Pablo Larraín completes his trilogy of biopics spotlighting women who shaped the 20th century. Following Jackie (2016), where Natalie Portman portrayed Jackie Onassis, and Spencer (2021), starring Kristen Stewart as Lady Diana, this film casts Angelina Jolie in a surprising and transformative performance as Callas. Jolie not only embodies the role with grace but also lends her voice to the singing. However, despite its poignancy, the screenplay— penned by Steven Knight (Dirty Pretty Things, 2002; Eastern Promises, 2007)—falters in delivering emotional resonance in pivotal moments. 

At 53, Maria lives in Paris, haunted by a traumatic childhood in Athens and the realization that her voice, once unparalleled, has faltered. Alternating between reality and imagination, she leans on her devoted butler Ferruccio (Pierfrancesco Favino) and housemaid Bruna (Alba Rohrwacher) for support. Flashbacks, rendered in stark black-and-white, vividly illustrate her turbulent teenage years and her fraught relationship with the charismatic but domineering Aristotle Onassis (Haluk Bilginer).

Filmed with grandeur and sophistication, Maria eschews melodramatic artifice but probably could've benefited from a little more energy in its telling. While polished and coherent, the drama feels predictably prepackaged. Larraín and Jolie keep the picture moving, yet struggling to showcase how the diva’s trauma and health decline affected her final artistic aspirations. 

The period details are meticulously crafted, and Ed Lachman’s cinematography is nothing short of stunning, but the staging constantly oscillates between elegant mannerism and calibrated realism. Maria is dispensable, and only Jolie’s masterful performance can make it a worthwhile watch for admirers of the actress and the opera icon alike.

Gladiator II (2024)

Direction: Ridley Scott
Country: USA 

Ridley Scott cements his reputation as a master of epic cinema with Gladiator II, an arguably unnecessary but undeniably entertaining action spectacle that revels in physical clashes and dramatic intensity. Written by David Scarpa, this sequel introduces Paul Mescal as Lucius Verus Aurelius, the son of Maximus (played by Russell Crowe in the original).

Fifteen years after Maximus’ death, Lucius returns to a corrupt Rome after the Roman army's brutal campaign in Numidia, North Africa. Haunted by the murder of his wife, he vows vengeance, reconnects with his mother, Lucilla (Connie Nielsen), and finds himself under the tutelage of Macrinus (Denzel Washington), a former slave with ambitions to rule Rome. 

While it breaks no new ground narratively, this colossal production builds momentum as it unfolds, eventually drawing viewers into its dramatic core. It is a visceral, blood-soaked exploration of power, war, revenge, and emancipation, holding the audience captive with its steamy visuals and audacious premise. The fight sequences erupt with the force of a volcano, and Scott elicits compelling performances from his cast. 

Despite its shortcomings, Gladiator II delivers a full-bodied adventure that skillfully balances responsiveness to its audience’s expectations with a reverence for the epic grandeur of its predecessor.

Wicked (2024)

Direction: Jon M. Chu
Country: USA 

Jon M. Chu (Crazy Rich Asians, 2018; In The Heights, 2021) delivers a competent adaptation of the renowned Broadway musical Wicked, inspired by the world of The Wizard of Oz. This is the first installment of a two-part adaptation, written by Winnie Holzman and Dana Fox (Cruella, 2021). 

Selling every scene they’re in, Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande form an amazing duo as Elphaba and Galinda, respectively. The former character was born green with special psychic powers but was rejected by her father, eventually becoming the Wicked Witch of the West after her sorcery tutor, Madame Morrible (Michelle Yeoh), arranges a fateful meeting with the Wizard of Oz (Jeff Goldblum). In contrast, Galinda is an irritating, self-absorbed, glamorous blonde steeped in vanity and artificiality. Despite their differences—spoiled versus neglected, vain versus humble—the two women form a meaningful friendship and even fall for the same man. 

Chu stays true to the spirit of the musical, amplifying its socio-political themes. The story’s messages of inclusion, acceptance of differences, resistance against oppression, and opposition to animal cruelty resonate powerfully. Despite technically sumptuous, Wicked doesn’t always 'defy gravity’, with some musical numbers feeling overly prolonged. Nevertheless, the film offers solid entertainment, blending the whimsy of Harry Potter with the flair of Barbie. It transports viewers into a vibrant, magical world that balances humor and poignancy with bursts of energy. 

As a mass-market confection, Wicked certainly works well enough, though its greatest strengths lie in its opulent production design and sharp humor rather than its narrative depth.

My Old Ass (2024)

Direction: Megan Park
Country: Canada

Megan Park’s sophomore directorial feature, My Old Ass, is a refreshingly spontaneous coming-of-age comedy that captures the vibrant, messy tapestry of teenage life with authenticity and warmth. At the heart of the film is a breakout performance by Canadian singer and actress Maisy Stella, making her feature film debut after her time on the musical television series Nashville.

Stella is Elliott, an 18-year-old who, during the course of a mushrooms trip, has contact with her 39-year-old self (Aubrey Plaza). What begins as a quirky exchange of life advice quickly becomes a heartfelt exploration of self-discovery, as Elliott grapples with the rebelliousness of youth and the unpredictable outcomes of love. 

Sweet but not cheesy, the film stands out for its originality and relatable charm. While it may not reinvent the teen rom-com genre, it handles themes like sexual orientation with a light, natural touch, brimming with hopefulness, self-discovery, and a sense of wonder about life and love.

Park, who impressed audiences with The Fallout in 2021, opts for simplicity, focusing on genuine human connection. This approach succeeds largely due to the chemistry of her leads, with Stella’s Elliott beautifully complemented by Percy Hynes White’s performance. My Old Ass is a gutsy and endearing ode to youth, a well-crafted tale of living life to its fullest and confronting the inevitable fear of loss. It’s an enjoyable, life-affirming watch that will leave you smiling, even if its charm is more fleeting than indelible.

His Three Daughters (2024)

Direction: Azazel Jacobs
Country: USA 

His Three Daughters, the seventh feature by Azazel Jacobs (The Lovers, 2017; French Exit, 2020), is a skillfully crafted chamber drama with richly drawn characters and a credible story. Set in a New York apartment, the film revolves around three estranged daughters who gather at their dying father’s home, bracing for his imminent passing. 

Rachel (Natasha Lyonne) is a heavy weed smoker who has been living with their father and apparently seems disconnected of everything and everyone. Katie (Carrie Coon), in stark contrast, is rigid, irritable, and excessively controlling. Christina (Elizabeth Olsen), the most conciliatory of the three, is more emotional and never complains about life. Little by little, we learn their cracks, their feelings, and certain aspects of their relationships that allow us to have a nuanced perspective on their shared history and personal struggles. These revelations build toward a restrained yet poignant finale.

While the story is undeniably familiar, Jacobs transforms it into a deeply absorbing experience, imbuing the film with both soul and bitterness. All three leads do quality work in a 100-minute showcase of talent, portraying complex and worth meeting characters.

Death becomes one of the tragic figures in this scenario, and there’s something in the creative spark behind Jacobs’ vision that sets it apart. His look at sisterhood isn’t intended to be perfect, opting instead for an honest portrayal of clashing personalities and the ways they soften in the face of shared grief. Although you won’t find anything unexpected here, a naturalistic tone is maintained throughout, which crackles with an emotional energy and cackles with a repentant laughter.

A Different Man (2024)

Direction: Aaron Schimberg
Country: USA

A Different Man is a bold and provocative tragicomic fable that takes flight with its offbeat details and quirky, unexpected situations. Written and directed by Aaron Schimberg (Chained For Life, 2019), this darkly twisted story follows Edward Lemuel (Sebastian Stan), a reserved man whose life takes a dramatic turn after undergoing major facial reconstructive surgery to treat neurofibromatosis—a rare genetic condition that causes tumors and malformations. Emerging with a new identity as Guy Moratz, Edward starts working as an actor with his playwright neighbor Ingrid (Renate Reinsve), who is staging an off-Broadway play about his former life. Yet, his fresh start takes a sinister turn when he becomes fixated on Oswald (Adam Pearson), an actor with neurofibromatosis cast to portray the old Edward. 

The film’s offbeat jazz soundtrack gives this satire an awesome ambiance, making it undeniably fun and bonkers in ways that only weird movies can be. Schimberg’s confident direction balances whimsy with profundity, crafting a small symphony of enchanting disharmony that occasionally flirts with implausibility but never loses its edge. Through its blend of humor and pathos, the film explores themes of ego, ambition, affirmation, and unrequited love, offering a thoughtful meditation on the power and perils of transformation. 

Imaginative, subtly disconcerting, and solidly performed, A Different Man infuses a dry sense of humor while packing a cathartic emotional punch throughout. It won’t leave you indifferent.

The Damned (2024)

Direction: Roberto Minervini
Country: USA / Italy / Belgium

Roberto Minervini’s The Damned is a stark and minimalist war drama that eschews grandiose battle scenes in favor of an intimate focus on individuals caught in the relentless grip of the American Civil War. Set during the brutal winter of 1862, the film follows a group of Union volunteers tasked with patrolling the uncharted Western Territories. The soldiers must navigate treacherous, snow-covered landscapes and endure the punishing cold, all while grappling with existential reflections on faith, patriotism, family, and survival. 

Even if the film offers some intriguing meditations on its weighty themes, the narrative feels overly pared down, delivering little in the way of tension or excitement. Minervini’s restrained direction keeps viewers at a frustrating emotional distance, making it difficult to connect with or fully invest in the characters. The most striking thing about The Damned is how ordinary it is, feeling like a moody vignette rather than a fully realized story. Unfortunately, it doesn’t come with sufficient layers to suss out.

In the Summers (2024)

Direction: Alessandra Lacorazza Samudio
Country: USA 

Colombian-American writer-director Alessandra Lacorazza Samudio makes a positive impression with her audacious feature debut, In The Summers. This semi-autobiographical drama follows two sisters, embodied with nuance by Sasha Calle and Lio Mehiel, as they navigate the complexities of spending summers with their emotionally unstable, alcoholic Puerto Rican-born father (René Pérez) in Las Cruces, New Mexico. Structured in four evocative chapters, the film poignantly captures the relentless passage of time and the enduring impact of familial bonds. 

Rooted in raw authenticity, In the Summers unfolds with deliberate pacing, relying on moments of painful silence and emotionally charged dilemmas to tell its story. The chemistry between father and daughters is unsettling yet compelling, keeping viewers uneasy and attuned to the tension simmering beneath the surface.

Samudio’s direction is marked by precision and restraint, focusing on small yet significant details and situational clarity. The performances are heartfelt and layered, while the film’s formally measured approach draws viewers into its meditative exploration of connection, resilience, and the scars left by those we love most.

The Apprentice (2024)

Direction: Ali Abbasi
Country: USA 

After the lukewarm reception of Holy Spider (2022), Iranian-born Danish filmmaker Ali Abbasi finds his stride with The Apprentice, his first English-language film. This biopic, penned by journalist and author Gabriel Sherman, employs artful dramatization to delve into the dark, tension-filled world of political intrigue. The film focuses on a young Donald Trump (Sebastian Stan) and his mentor Roy Cohn (Jeremy Strong), a ruthless and influential lawyer whose teachings shape Trump’s infamous playbook for success: attack relentlessly, deny all accusations, and never admit defeat.

Set against the backdrop of 1970s New York, the narrative explores Trump's rise from financial turmoil to prominence, emphasizing his morally ambiguous dealings and relationships. Key figures in his life, including his cold father (Martin Donovan), his first wife Ivana (Maria Bakalova), and his troubled brother Fred (Charlie Carrick), an airline pilot grappling with alcoholism and depression, add depth to the character study. 

The Apprentice is an ugly story with its quibbles and flaws, but I watched it with interest from start to finish. There are a few controversial scenes—it’s hard to determine how much of each is true and how much is false—but the personifications are remarkable, the pace is exciting, and the real ambition felt throughout is an aspect that intrigues. The film, elevated by its two lead actors and the compelling cinematography by Kasper Tuxen (Beginners, 2010; The Worst Person in the World, 2021), is a complex and scary portrait of a man whose thirst for power can have a major impact on our world.

Separated (2024)

Direction: Errol Morris
Country: USA 

After reading Separated: Inside an American Tragedy by journalist Jacob Soboroff, acclaimed documentarian Errol Morris (The Thin Blue Line, 1988; The Fog of War, 2003) was compelled to adapt it into a film. The documentary tackles the Trump administration’s ‘zero tolerance’ immigration policy that led to the traumatic separation of migrant parents and children. The resulting film is informative but not particularly engaging, blending interviews with an arguably unnecessary fictionalized depiction of a Guatemalan mother and son’s border crossing, played by Gabriela Cartol and Diego Armando Lara Lagunes.

Soboroff is featured in the film as well as former major figures at the Office of Refugee Resettlement, Cptn. Jonathan White and Scott Lloyd. White’s assertive critique contrasts starkly with Lloyd’s visible discomfort, underscoring the policy’s damaging impact. Due to extended media coverage, most of the details feel overly familiar, and yet it effectively captures the policy’s inhumane implications, serving as a sobering reminder of the need for accountability.

Separated is cleanly arrayed but feels somewhat timid as a terrifying wake-up call that makes us want a better America. Though not groundbreaking, this political documentary tells us we all need to demand more from our politicians, advocating for a more compassionate solution.

Woman of the Hour (2024)

Direction: Anna Kendrick
Country: USA 

Anna Kendrick steps into the director’s chair with confidence and purpose in her debut film, Woman of the Hour. Based on a screenplay by Ian McDonald, the film recounts the story of notorious serial killer Rodney Alcala, who eluded authorities for nearly a decade due to systemic negligence. Known as the “Dating Game Killer” after his appearance on the popular 1978 show, Alcala worked briefly as a typesetter at the Los Angeles Times while carrying out his gruesome murders.

In the film, Kendrick plays fictional character Sheryl Bradshaw, a struggling actress from Pennsylvania who encounters Alcala (Daniel Zovatto) on The Dating Game. Blending dark and satirical tones, Woman of the Hour reveals Alcala’s brutal acts across Los Angeles, Wyoming, New York, and San Gabriel, exposing the misogyny and systemic failures that allowed him to remain undetected.

Kendrick delivers an effectively unsettling film—directing without unnecessary embellishment, allowing the stark horror of the crimes to speak for itself. Zovatto brings a deeply unnerving intensity to Alcala, adding layers of dread each time he’s on screen. Though Woman of the Hour doesn’t delve deeply into Alcala's backstory, its straightforward approach and restrained style make it a chilling, sharply crafted thriller that lingers in the mind.

Beetlejuice Beetlejuice (2024)

Direction: Tim Burton
Country: USA

The much-vaunted return of Tim Burton, who rose to fame with films such as Edward Scissorhands (1990), Ed Wood (1994), and Sweeney Todd (2007), happens with Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, a visually inventive yet flawed sequel to his 1988 cult classic. Despite the 36-year gap, the original ‘80s vibe lingers in this formulaic work, whether you call it absurdist supernatural comedy or macabre dark fantasy or both. Michael Keaton returns, reprising his role as the trickster demon, as well as Winona Ryder as psychic Lydia Deetz, and Catherine O’Hara as her eccentric stepmother, Delia. The cast expands with Monica Belucci as a stitched-up, soul-sucking ghost, joined by Danny De Vito, Jenna Ortega, Willem Defoe, and Justin Theroux. Unlike the others, the latter two had never worked with the director before.

While packed with Burton’s trademark surrealism, the plot — scripted by Alfred Gough and Miles Millar — feels chaotic, marked by frantic pacing, loose subplots, and forgettable villains. The film tries to balance nostalgia for long-time fans with attempts to win over a new generation but often feels like a haphazard spectacle. Despite its energetic antics and quirky visuals, Beetlejuice Beetlejuice lacks the cohesion needed to truly captivate, leaving audiences dizzy yet unsatisfied. When the credits roll, you may feel you’ve spent 104 minutes in a world of Burton-esque antics, but without much of a payoff.

Lee (2024)

Direction: Ellen Kuras
Country: USA

This biographical drama about Vogue model turned war photographer Lee Miller falls into the traps of flashback-heavy storytelling that fails to fully capture the intensity of a life shaped by the adrenaline of war. Starring Kate Winslet, who championed the project and handpicked director Ellen Kuras along with the rest of the cast, the film delivers a conventional narrative that lacks the rhythm and inspiration needed to depict Miller's struggles as a daring photographer fighting for validation in a male-dominated world.

This well-intentioned but toothless biopic feels academic; its staging remains cold and distant when it should pulse with emotion. The scenes follow one another mechanically, and even the final twist fails to lift the film from its overarching sense of banality. Lee Miller, a fascinating figure, deserved a more compelling tribute, as this portrayal of her life does little beyond the bare minimum. Sadly, Lee feels inexplicably stiff.

Joker: Folie a Deux (2024)

Direction: Todd Phillips
Country: USA 

Five years after the remarkable Joker, its sequel, Folie à Deux, feels more like a crowd-pleasing cabaret show than a gripping psychological thriller. Directed once again by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, the film fails to capture even half the impact of its predecessor. While attempting to juggle multiple genres—a courtroom drama, a depressive musical, a twisted love story, and a social satire—it ultimately collapses under the weight of its own ambitions. 

Lady Gaga co-stars as the manipulative Lee, also known as Harley Quinn, singing mediocrely throughout and showing little to no chemistry with Phoenix. Their bizarre romance lacks the emotional depth needed to sustain the story, and the film looks too self-absorbed in showing the viewers how quirky and moving it thinks it really is. Meaningless and unnecessarily long, Folie a Deux is less and less appealing as it lurched toward the end. If you’re expecting chills or thrills, you'll be disappointed. The inclusion of jazz standards disrupts any potential for the sinister, unsettling atmosphere one might expect from a film centered on iconic supervillains.

Despite these shortcomings, Phoenix always fascinates, though even his brilliance can’t salvage the awkward plot. The film never fully draws you in, but for fans of Phoenix, his performance may be the only saving grace in an otherwise lackluster sequel.

Wolfs (2024)

Direction: Jon Watts
Country: USA

Inspired by his admiration for solitary anti-heroes in films such as Le Samourai (1967), Ghost Dog (1999), and Collateral (2004), director Jon Watts sets up a New York crime story in Wolfs, but most of it feels worn-out and lackluster. This film reunites Brad Pitt and George Clooney, who portray experienced crime scene cleaners having extreme difficulties teaming up as requested by their clients. 

The film’s intriguing opening is engaging but it quickly unravels, descending into shallow banter, self-mockery (mostly revolving around aging), and formulaic action scenes toward oblivion. Though it initially seems to channel Coen Brothers’ dark, quirky tone, it takes a wrong turn, injecting syrupy moments that come off as laughably ridiculous and will likely irritate genre fans.

Wolfs is clumsy, overly formulaic, and incompetently lazy, following a banal, unoriginal plot weighed down by cheesy dialogue and underbaked story elements. Lacking any type of genius, it’s a waste of talent and energy on all levels.

Megalopolis (2024)

Direction: Francis Ford Coppola
Country: USA 

After more than 40 years in development, Francis Ford Coppola finally unveils Megalopolis, an ambitious sci-fi epic he largely financed himself. The idea for this eccentric, dense film came to Coppola during the making of Apocalypse Now, raising high expectations. However, despite its long gestation, Megalopolis unfolds as a bloated soap-opera-like spectacle that struggles under the weight of its convoluted themes and sprawling subjects.

The story follows Cesar Catilina (Adam Driver), a brilliant yet enigmatic visionary with a controversial past and the ability to stop time. His grand ambition is to construct a utopian “city of the future” in New Rome. However, his dream faces fierce opposition from the city’s conservative mayor, Franklyn Cicero (Giancarlo Esposito), while he finds both love and support in Cicero’s daughter, Julia (Nathalie Emmanuel), a medical school dropout.

Though the film nods to cinematic classics like Brazil (1985), Metropolis (1927), and Dark City (1998), it feels soulless. Despite the weighty themes of political struggle, futuristic utopia, and satirical pop culture, the film feels surprisingly naive, a grab bag of ancient sci-fi ideas and plastic performances that fail to provoke. Copolla dedicated the film to his late wife but Megalopolis is already seen as the greatest disappointment of the year.

Between the Temples (2024)

Direction: Nathan Silver
Country: USA

Directed and co-written by Nathan Silver, the comedy-drama Between the Temples strives to be quirky and offbeat, but ultimately misses the mark. Starring Jason Schwartzman and Carol Kane, the film is staged with a bunch of embarrassments that feel more flat than profound. 

The story revolves around Benjamin Gottlieb (Schwartzman), a 40-year-old kosher cantor struggling to cope with the death of his wife. He finds a glimmer of hope in Carla Kessler (Kane), his former music teacher, whom he agrees to help prepare for a late-in-life bat mitzvah. 

While the premise holds promise, the execution falters. The film never finds its rhythm, frequently losing momentum just when it should be gaining traction. Lacking the wit and style it aspires to, Between the Temples tries to inject energy into situations that implode under the weight of its own excessive pressure. 

Despite satisfactory performances from Schwartzman and Kane, the result is disappointingly televisual, culminating in a bewildering climax, full of emotional swings, that is the opposite of a knockoff. Not much in the material stimulates, and the film, sloppily rendered and off-punttingly screwy, doesn’t leave an impression.

Daddio (2024)

Direction: Christy Hall
Country: USA

Christy Hall's feature debut, Daddio, is a lackluster two-character drama that desperately seeks attention but fails to capture any. Set during a long cab ride from JFK airport to midtown Manhattan, the film—originally conceived as a stage play—stars Sean Penn as a chatty, self-important cab driver and Dakota Johnson as his passenger, a seemingly confident yet emotionally fragile woman returning to New York after visiting her estranged half-sister in Oklahoma. 

Visually dull and conversationally uninspired, Daddio lacks depth, maturity, and emotional resonance. The dialogue, filled with shallow confessions, unearned conclusions, and awkward laughs, does little to develop the characters beyond superficial traits. Penn's occasional watery eyes never feel authentic, and it's hard to believe Johnson's forced nonchalance and sudden curiosity about a stranger who seems to read and understand her. 

At its core, Daddio is void of any spark or substance. The film trudges along without ever offering anything fresh or meaningful, leaving the audience to wonder: why should we care? It feels like watching paint dry—only less captivating. 

The Substance (2024)

Direction: Coralie Fargeat
Country: USA

Coralie Fargeat’s sophomore feature, The Substance, is set to be hailed as the shock film of the year. A grotesque blend of body horror with sharp satirical overtones, it escalates in bizarre intensity until it reaches the brink of madness.

The film stars Demi Moore as Elisabeth Sparkle, an aging TV star who injects a miraculous substance designed to unlock her DNA, creating a younger, more beautiful version of herself. That version is played with mischievous charm by Margaret Qualley. However, Sparkle fails to adhere to the crucial condition—switch bodies every seven days—and struggles to comprehend the delicate balance needed for both versions to coexist.

The pumped up narrative swirls us up in this woman's obsession, invoking the transgressive and visceral visual traits reminiscent of David Cronenberg and John Carpenter. At its best, the film maintains a tense and unnerving atmosphere, but just as it has you on the edge of your seat, it spirals into gratuitous violence and excessive gore.

Fargeat's creation is undeniably horrific, but she pushes it too far, especially in the final act. The relentless gore feels less like a narrative necessity and more like a transgressive indulgence, ultimately undermining the careful creepiness that initially made it gripping. The last section is so filthy and exaggerated that it risks alienating viewers, leaving one to wonder why the director chose to tarnish what could have been a chillingly effective film.

The Substance is nauseating but undeniably powerful, shocking yet audacious. It’s an outrageously bloodthirsty dark fantasy that demands a strong stomach. Had Fargeat reined in the excess, it could have been a standout horror. Nevertheless, both Moore and Qualley deliver striking performances.