Io Capitano (2023)

Direction: Matteo Garrone
Country: Italy / Belgium/ France

Io Capitano is a breathtaking migrant odyssey directed and co-written by Matteo Garrone, renowned for works such as Gomorrah (2008) and Dogman (2018). The film, devoid of cynicism and cheap sentimentality, follows the perilous journey of two 16-year-old Senegalese boys who decide to leave Dakar for Europe. Their journey, full of surprises and strong emotions, exposes the harsh realities of racism, exploitation, and inhumanity, while also providing a lesson in courage, humility, and humanism. 

Garrone navigates new territory with a firm hand, shedding light on the tenebrous predicaments associated with migration and raising awareness of human rights violations. Beyond its value as a fictional tale, Io Capitano serves as a profound statement on the challenges faced by migrants. 

The cinematography by Paolo Carnera captures vast expanses of desert and ocean, adding to the film's visual appeal, while newcomer actor Seydou Sarr, who is like a shinning beam of light in a dark place, delivers a credible performance, conveying innocence and affability. Even though the script may not reach great majesty, Io Capitano remains an indispensable movie about a disturbing global issue with no immediate solution at sight. Its path evokes both touching and shocking emotions simultaneously.

Eileen (2023)

Direction: William Oldroyd
Country: USA

Directed by William Oldroyd (Lady Macbeth, 2016), Eileen is an adaptation of Ottessa Moshfegh’s debut novel of the same name, with a screenplay by Moshfegh herself and Luke Goebel. It’s a soggy slow burn depicted with formal pomp and impressive cinematography that, gradually, goes from intriguing to banal.

The plot follows Eileen (Thomasin McKenzie), a bored and lonely young woman who lives with her alcoholic father (Shea Whigham), a troubled ex-cop, and works in a juvenile detention facility as an assistant. Her routine takes a strange turn when Rebecca (Anne Hathaway), a confident psychologist and graduated from Harvard, arrives at New England, bringing some fantasy into her life but also chaos. Both women share a special interest in Lee Polk (Sam Nivola), a kid who mysteriously stabbed his father to death in his sleep. 

Eileen is better characterized than Rebecca, who appears more enigmatic, and the flatness of the story is intermittently interrupted by the former’s grace. However, as a noir psychological thriller, the film fails to raise its staging to exceptional heights, remaining more or less nailed to the ground. It’s all done mechanically, without the brilliance that would have captivated the audience. 

Sensuality, desire, and depressive insanity are predominant factors in a story that recites all the commonplaces of the genre without possessing the sophistication of its models. Despite incorporating some twists that force changes in direction, Eileen falls short of being exciting, concluding with a rushed ending that lacks surprise or shock. What remains is just the idea of something uncomfortably bland.

How to Have Sex (2023)

Direction: Molly Manning Walker
Country: UK / Greece

In this conventional coming-of-age drama film, written and directed by debutant English filmmaker Molly Manning Walker, the narrative subtly questions consent and explores the emptiness of youths rushing to embrace adulthood. The film delves into sexual and emotional disillusion, unreliable friendships, and ultimately hope. It starts as a lascivious, energetic romp with quick editing but evolves into a hard-nosed, somewhat schematized summer adventure before the too easy ending. 

The plot revolves around three British friends - Tara (Mia McKenna-Bruce), Em (Enva Lewis), and Skye (Lara Peake) - who embarks on a trip to a party resort in Malia, located on the Greek island of Crete, with the intention of having fun. Tara, in particular, feels the societal pressure of still being a virgin, and the film explores how the 'dream' surrounding a first sexual experience often falls short of expectations.

While the initial segment may not be particularly surprising, the film gains more depth as the real problem emerges, exposing those gray areas associated with the topic with realistic perception. What you thought would happen, does... with no less traumatizing nuance that, for moments, takes the form of a sun-and-sea-kissed nightmare. Despite moments where the plot feels like a rough draft, the tension simmering beneath the surface is undeniable. The way the 16-year-old protagonist is tempted and entrapped is portrayed with authenticity, and McKenna-Bruce capably conveys the emotional tumult associated with such a transformative experience.

Society of the Snow (2023)

Direction: Juan Antonio Bayona
Country: Spain / USA

From the Spanish director of The Orphanage (2007) and The Impossible (2012), Juan Antonio Bayona, Society of the Snow is a moving tale of survival against all odds and a magnificent lesson in courage and hope. Adapting Pablo Vierci’s book of the same name, Bayona, along with his three co-writing associates, solidly depicts the 1972 crash in the Andes Mountains of an Uruguayan Air Force plane transporting a rugby team from Montevideo to Santiago. 16 people miraculously survive in unimaginable conditions after 72 days of being stranded, facing extreme cold, hunger, and complex moral dilemmas.

The film provides an uncomfortable viewing experience, offering an overwhelming and anguishing account of a terrible accident. The cumulative visual effects is powerful enough to get you caught in the gut, exposing horror and suffering at different levels while also enhancing the courage and the hope of these brave men with stunning precision and grueling agitation.

The movie's greatest strength lies in its visuals, supported by a nausea-inspiring sense of survivalism that shifts gears into noble acts of kindness, compassion, and collective trust. The plane crash is breathtaking in its technical magnificence, but the emotions, despite numerous close-ups and moments of high tension, ebb and flow.

Having said that, while Society of the Snow may not be a constant nail-biter, there’s enough of an emotional engine driving interest in the story. Magnified by Pedro Luque’s sharp cinematography, this stress-inducing film offers a sensory experience tcapable of accelerating your heartbeat and diverting your mind from minor troubles.

All Dirt Roads Taste of Salt (2023)

Direction: Raven Jackson
Country: USA 

Counting on Barry Jenkins, the director of Moonlight (2016) and If Beale Street Could Talk (2018), as a producer, All Dirt Roads Taste of Salt marks the directorial debut of Raven Jackson, a poet and photographer from Tennessee. The film is a contemplative drama that serves as a memoir spanning 50 years, recounting the story of Mackenzie, a Black teenage girl who grapples with an unexpected pregnancy in Mississippi. 

The film’s interesting premise deteriorates due to a sluggish pace, monotonous conception, and sparse dialogue. The floating structure and dreamy aura contribute to a sense of sadness, but they may hinder a deeper exploration of the elements at play, and the long shots and quietness dip the film in exasperation. It’s an overlong experience that tests the audience's patience while struggling to make a lasting emotional impact.

Even radiating intimacy at times, All Dirt Roads Taste of Salt fails to validate a lasting claim on the heart. The narrative, relying heavily on images rather than words, could be told in ten minutes. As a result, there’s simply not enough here to really engage.

Ferrari (2023)

Direction: Michael Mann
Country: USA

The accomplished director Michael Mann, known for films like The Last of the Mohicans (1992), Collateral (2004), and Ali (2001), brings his expertise to this biographical sports drama centered around Enzo Ferrari, the renowned Italian entrepreneur and founder of the Ferrari Grand Prix motor racing team. Written by Troy Kennedy Martin, based on the biopic Enzo Ferrari: The Man, the Cars, the Races, the Machine by journalist Brock Yates, the film delves into Enzo’s business challenges, his tumultuous relationship with wife and business associate Laura Domenica Garello, his solace found in mistress Lina Lardi and their son, and his drivers of choice - in particular Alfonso de Portago. 

Adam Driver and Penelope Cruz give a pair of excellent performances as husband and wife, contributing considerably to the relative success of a film that revealed to be less exciting than initially expected. There are some spectacular racing sequences but the film misses greater opportunities to shine and ultimately wobbles in its struggle to hold our interest. Essentially, the emotions are subdued, compromising the film’s provocative intents. Having said that, and despite some occasional dragging pace, the narrative follows logically, and the facts are delivered with no major flaws or startles.

As a result, half the audience will gasp at the drama, while the the other half - the auto racing enthusiasts - may seize the moment to deepen their historic background on Ferrari team and its founder.

American Fiction (2023)

Direction: Cord Jefferson
Country: USA 

American Fiction unfolds as an open-hearted comedy drama with spun fast and sharp dialogue where humor prevails even in the midst of poignant moments. It’s a remarkable feature debut for Cord Jefferson, whose curious perspective and narrative intelligence keep a tight focus on the central character. He makes the film a powerful triumph.

The story centers on Thelonious “Monk” Ellison, portrayed by Jeffrey Wright, a talented yet frustrated Black author and English professor. Under a pseudonym, Monk writes a deliberately clichéd satirical novel that exposes the hypocrisy of the publishing industry and white consumerism. Accused of not being ‘Black enough’ in his writings, Monk grapples with death and illness in the family, and contends with the success of a new literary sensation: Sintara Golden (Issa Rae), whom he deems a fraud. Additionally, he reconnects with his estranged brother, Cliff (Sterling K. Brown), a messy plastic surgeon, and navigates a complex love story with Coraline (Erika Alexander), a lawyer living across the street from his mom. 

Sensitive in so many ways but also confrontational, the film is a brazenly enlightening, stingingly thought-provoking satire that straddles the realms of drama and comedy, making its point. It’s one of those pictures that remains engaging, even in its silliest scenes, ultimately achieving an airy result considering such weighty thematic loads. 

Brilliant casting and a cleverly woven story ensure that funny, angry, and heartbreaking moments blend seamlessly. Wright, who played the leading role in Julian Schnabel’s Basquiat (1996) and has been featured in Wes Anderson’s latest works - The French Dispatch (2021) and Asteroid City (2023) - plays his character with mordancy, virtuosity, and blistering perfection, delivering a career-high performance. Also, composer Laura Karpman infuses some wonderful musical vibes, leaning more towards cool piano jazz than the angular style of Thelonious Monk. 
American Fiction presents itself in a distinctive cinematic fashion, leaving a lasting impact on its audience.

Poor Things (2023)

Direction: Yorgos Lanthimos
Country: USA

Greek-born filmmaker Yorgos Lanthimos is able to keep audiences in giddy laughter or shocking horror. Known for his unique storytelling in films like Dogtooth (2009), The Lobster (2015), and The Favourite (2018), he presents his latest black comedy, Poor Things. Adapted from Alasdair Gray's 1992 novel, the film is written by Tony McNamara and features a stellar cast, including Emma Stone, Willem Dafoe, Mark Ruffalo, and Ramy Youssef.

The film follows the story of Bella (Stone), a candid young Victorian woman brought back to life by the eccentric surgeon Dr. Godwin Baxter (Dafoe). With newfound free will, Bella embarks on a journey of self-discovery, choosing to explore life with its pleasures and challenges. Her unconventional choices, including running away with lawyer Duncan Wedderburn (Ruffalo), will teach her many things, ultimately sending her back to an unimaginable past of darkness.

Gorgeously rendered, the film offers a smart and eccentric exploration of society and the human experience. An ambitious idea framed with visual distinction and spirited performances, where vertiginous philosophical foundations merge with a strong determination in self-learning and sexual liberation. This sinister tale is hilarious in spots, persistently full of life (despite dealing with death), and provocative as the hip filmmaker likes to shape his off-kilter comedies. 

With its moody soundscape by Jerkin Fendrix and superb cinematography by Robbie Ryan, Poor Things is the standout unconventional comedy of the year. Lanthimos continues to surprise audiences with his daring imagination, offering a fresh and intoxicating cinematic experience.

Godzilla Minus One (2023)

Direction: Takashi Yamazaki
Country: Japan

If you enjoy adventure films with a combination of intense action and dramatic flair, Godzilla Minus One might be the movie for you. Directed by Japanese filmmaker Takashi Yamazaki, the film offers a visceral and fast-paced fantasy with striking visuals and a strong sense of conviction. Yamazaki employs blockbuster tactics to depict multiple dangerous situations with a radioactive Godzilla wreaking havoc on a postwar Japan. 

The story revolves around Koichi Shikishima (Ryunosuke Kamiki), a former kamikaze pilot turned deserter and sea-mine extractor. His lack of courage brings shame to many of his fellow countrymen. However, when he encounters Noriko Oishi and her rescued orphan baby, he discovers a new purpose in life. As Godzilla heads to Tokyo, Koichi sees an opportunity to redeem himself and prove his bravery and piloting skills.

The film explores strong anti-patriotic sentiments associated with the loss of war, mixed with a sense of unity among a group of civilians led by former naval weapons engineer and strategist Kenji Noda (Hidetaka Yoshioka). Despite some plot holes and sentimental moments, Yamazaki enhances the film with stylized visuals, well-composed frames, and knockout sequences that blend ferocity with desolation. The director bends the rules of the genre by providing reinforced visual effects and relying on an intense musical score. While Godzilla's new roar is a result of a simple amplification of the original, the overall experience feels fresh and new.

Maestro (2023)

Direction: Bradley Cooper
Country: USA

Directed by and starring Bradley Cooper, Maestro is a well-crafted representation of the enduring marriage between iconic conductor and composer Leonard Bernstein and his actress wife Felicia Montealegre. The film avoids messiness in its timeline, presenting an honest and mature biopic that excels on all fronts.

The story, spanning 30 years, starts with a prologue where Bernstein is filmed and interviewed at home, but the story quickly winds back to his conducting debut with the New York Philharmonic at Carnegie Hall and his rapid rise to fame in 1943. Then, it focuses on the couple and how they changed over the years as he embraces the absolute freedom of the artist, sometimes recklessly. Despite betrayals and jealousy, their love proves to be resilient.

Cooper, who co-wrote with Josh Singer (Spotlight, 2015; First Man, 2018), not only delivers his best directorial work - I wasn’t particularly a fan of A Star is Born (2018) - but also his best performance, creating an extremely empathetic atmosphere that spans a wide range of emotions. Carey Mulligan’s earnest performance, the beauty of black-and-white and pastel-colored visuals by Darren Aronofsky’s regular cinematographer, Matthew Libatique, and the immaculate production, involving talents like Martin Scorsese and Steven Spielberg, contribute to the film's richness and tonal consistency. Maestro stands as a testament to Cooper's directorial and acting prowess.

Priscilla (2023)

Direction: Sofia Copolla
Country: USA

Filmmaker Sofia Coppola has consistently impressed audiences with her unique perspectives and depictions in films like The Virgin Suicides (1999), Lost in Translation (2003), and Marie Antoinette (2006). In her latest work, Priscilla, a biographical drama based on Priscilla Presley’s memoir Elvis and Me, Coppola explores the turbulent journey and controversial relationship between the title character and the king of rock 'n' roll. 

The story begins when 14-year-old Priscilla Beaulieu is invited to a party in Germany and meets 24-year-old Elvis at the peak of his fame during military service. The initial fascination gradually fades over the years, marked by Elvis' aggressive reactions, addiction, and possessively toxic behavior. Priscilla goes from being a teen muse to a discarded wife.

Coppola, with the executive production assistance of Priscilla herself, creates an anti-fairy tale with sophisticated visuals. The film exudes earnest charm, and Cailee Spaeny, in a compelling performance, shines with incandescence. However, Jacob Elordi's portrayal of Elvis is unconvincing. While the film may lack a substantial plot or astounding revelations, and its tone becomes somewhat static, it is a gutsy, can’t-look-away work that captures the emptiness of a crumbling relationship.

Priscilla, painted with a filter of candor and maintaining its drive and passion, ultimately comes together nicely, more in the form of a dramatic whisper than a shout of affirmation.

Fast Charlie (2023)

Direction: Phillip Noyce
Country: USA 

Directed by Phillip Noyce, known for films like Rabbit-Proof Fence (2002) and The Quiet American (2002), Fast Charlie is an old-school action crime thriller that incorporates elements of romance, creating a contrast with its unremittingly violent scenes. Adapted from Victor Gischler’s novel Gun Monkeys, the film maintains a straightforward narrative, offering instant firmness and watchability. And there’s this sly humor that venomously assesses the lack of morality in the Southern mob lands.

Pierce Brosnan takes on the role of Charlie Swift, a hitman loyal to Stan (James Caan in his last role), an aging mob boss in Biloxi, Mississippi, for over 40 years. When a rival boss (Gbenga Akinnagbe) from New Orleans arrives, leaving a trail of death, Charlie is tasked with avenging the losses. He ends up teaming up with his crush, Marcie Kramer (Morena Baccarin), whose ex-husband was targeted by Charlie.

Sometimes ferocious, sometimes funny, occasionally feeling routine, Fast Charlie is an ambitious adaptation by Richard Wenk, offering a taste of 1980s action flicks, where a hero like Charlie could be played by Charles Bronson or Chuck Norris. 

Noyce's no-frills approach to the story is an asset, eschewing sensationalist tactics. Still, you may find yourself wishing less obvious, more demanding situations and a more substantial result. It could use a lot more discipline in key moments, but the nature of the story naturally supplies the required energy to keep us engaged regardless the predictability of the plot. For all that, Fast Charlie is a mildly entertaining little crime thumper that sufficiently delivers on its genre expectations.

Wonka (2023)

Direction: Paul King
Country: USA

In Paul King’s Wonka, a musical comedy that serves as a prequel to Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1971) and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (2005), a younger and creatively inclined Willy Wonka, portrayed by the French sensation Timothée Chalamet, takes his first steps in the art of making chocolate and magic. To establish his own business and make it prosper, Willy must contend with exploiters Mrs. Scrubitt (Olivia Colman) and her partner Bleacher (Tom Davis), along with a trio of envious businessmen and saboteurs controlling the Chocolate Cartel. Success might be elusive without the help of Noodle (Calah Lane), a young orphan girl, and Oompa-Lumpa (Hugh Grant), a small human who feeds on cocoa beans.

Visually sumptuous with deluxe, colorful settings, Wonka struggles to win hearts with its cardboard characters. The movie appears to lack a genuine sense of humor, and the script by King and Simon Farnaby relies on questionable options, resorting to overused cinematic tricks and treats.

As a sanitized tale that succumbs to the weight of its budget, Wonka comes across as formulaic and uninspiring. The excessive use of old-school songs becomes tedious, and the story lacks the expected magic and soul that usually populate this type of picture. The film falls short across the board, and even Chalamet's charm fails to elevate the bland cinematic flavors. At the very least, the film may leave you craving chocolate.

The Crime is Mine (2023)

Direction: François Ozon
Country: France

In François Ozon’s latest film, The Crime is Mine, the narrative follows Madeleine Verdier (Nadia Tereszkiewicz), a struggling young actress accused of murdering a renowned producer who had sexually assaulted her during an interview. Defended in court by her best friend and roommate, the unemployed lawyer Pauline (Rebecca Marder), they initially bask in fame until the iconic silent cinema actress, Odette Chaumette (a scene-stealing performance by Isabelle Huppert), claims responsibility for the crime.

Ozon, infusing the jazzy vibes of the 1930s, adapts a play from that era, creating a whimsical, feminist period farce filled with droll humor and a touch of charm. The film takes a lighthearted approach to murder, capturing the era's spirit through an abundance of color and a joyful atmosphere conveyed in briskly-paced, effortlessly chaotic scenes.

This stylized fusion of theater and cinema, infused with social satire, sarcasm, plenty of lies, and a blend of wacky and goofy moments, explores the burlesque side of screwball comedies. Drawing inspiration from the works of Ernst Lubitsch, Frank Capra, and Sacha Guitry, Ozon mounts the film with a refreshingly old-fashioned flair that doesn't come off as an ironic throwback or shameless nostalgia pandering. The production design is lavish and detailed, complemented by outstanding supporting performances from Fabrice Luchini and André Dussollier.

Less brilliant than 8 Women (2002), The Crime is Mine is performed with an impressive suppression of passion, but never losing sight of more serious aspects akin to today’s world. The elements may feel familiar, even hokum, but Ozon approaches the material with enthusiasm. The film ultimately rewards those seeking a light, feel-good piece of entertainment. 

Fremont (2023)

Direction: Babak Jalali
Country: USA 

Fremont marks the fourth feature film by Iranian-British director Babak Jalali, who co-wrote it with Carolina Cavalli (Amanda, 2022). This delightful and triumphant indie comedy-drama draws inspiration from the styles of Aki Kaurismaki and Jim Jarmusch. Languid and centered, the film is peppered with irresistible dry humor while addressing relevant topics with a philosophical tone and stoic expression.

The camera lens focuses on Donya (Anaita Wali Zada), an isolated 20-year-old Afghan refugee and former translator for the US Army, grappling with guilt, rejection, and melancholy for betraying her country. Working in a Chinese fortune cookie factory in San Francisco to avoid the large Afghan community in Fremont, she battles PTSD, leading her to seek help from Dr. Anthony (Gregg Turkington), a relaxed and patient psychiatrist. An unexpected blind date introduces her to Daniel (Jeremy Allen White), a lonely mechanic burdened with responsibilities. The intense connection she feels with him rekindles her ability to dream. 

Jalali handles narrative understatement with incredible charm, shooting in a beautiful black-and-white without succumbing to the common style-over-substance pitfall. The story - sharply observed, compellingly told, and crammed with agreeable surprises - appears to treat its weighty subjects with lightness and coldness. However, a deeper look proves that idea wrong. The humor pushes Fremont away from sentimental traps, and is complemented by a magnificently romantic section where the chemistry between Zara and White, both desperate for love, is remarkable.

The film's scenes are exposed with a non-cumbersome beauty that elicits tears without being overtly tearful. Fremont concludes with warmth and optimism, infusing independent cinema with a breath of fresh air and a generous heart.

The Teacher's Lounge (2023)

Direction: Ilker Çatak
Country: Germany

In The Teachers’ Lounge, Ilker Çatak’s fourth feature film, a well-intentioned yet naive young teacher, Carla Nowak (Leonie Benesch), finds herself entangled in a troubling situation spurred by a series of thefts at the German public school where she works. This skewed drama unfolds with a growing sense of discontent, occasionally adopting the intensity of a thriller.

Carla embarks on a clandestine investigation using questionable methods, only to discover a flawed scholar system, racial prejudice, and persistent manipulative tactics that hinder genuine problem-solving. The film captures her traumatic experience in a parent-teacher conference, and her difficulties in dealing with pressure from both cynical colleagues and aggressive students.

While the film raises thought-provoking questions about truth and justice, it refrains from providing definitive answers. Despite its noble intention to address contemporary classroom issues, the narrative loses momentum after a promising start, falling into the category of films that are admired more than enjoyed.

In reality, there's an element of outrage in this indirect call to civility, but the film feels somewhat slick and gimmicky. Moments with a stronger sense of real-life authenticity are juxtaposed with others featuring mannered dialogues and postures, causing the narrative to get bogged down in details. The Teachers’ Lounge could have been more involving, given its potential. 

A Male (2023)

Direction: Fabian Hernandez
Country: Colombia

A Male, the debut feature by Colombian filmmaker Fabian Hernandez, unfolds as a modest low-budget drama set in the unforgiving streets of Bogotá, dominated by gangs. The protagonist, Carlos (Dilan Felipe Ramírez Espitia), is a 16-year-old who lives in a youth shelter. The central character, Carlos (Dilan Felipe Ramírez Espitia), a 16-year-old residing in a youth shelter, grapples with a girly face and a fragile physique in the predominantly masculine and violent neighborhood. His sole aspiration revolves around surprising his incarcerated mother with a visit on Christmas Day. 

The premise holds promise, and we feel grateful for this is not your typical gangster or coming-of-age flick.  However, the potential dissipates rapidly as the narrative fails to build sufficient tension, never culminating in a compelling climax. The lonely boy's struggle to assert his toughness lacks the depth needed to resonate emotionally. While sensitive to the mix of sadness, bravery, and resolution within Carlos, the film stumbles in handling a subject that doesn’t cope well with melodramatic insistence. 

I was unable to connect with the protagonist and what he was going through. Perhaps the director lacked the skills to coax a psychologically complex performance out of the debutant actor. Hence, the film doesn’t deliver enough as each development is unadorned and plain, lessening in emotional power and culminating in an unsatisfying ending. Hernandez's exploration of a misfit in conflict with the toxic masculinity of his environment ultimately misses the mark.

May December (2023)

Direction: Todd Haynes
Country: USA

Todd Haynes stands out as a remarkable director, contributing to the cinematic landscape with noteworthy works such as Far From Heaven (2002), I’m Not There (2007), and Carol (2015). In his latest endeavor, May December, he delivers a quietly disturbing, character-driven film with a gratifying payoff, delving into themes like sexual manipulation and extreme journalism. The narrative revolves around a woman who, at 36, initiated a sexual relationship with a 13-year-old, drawing inspiration from the real-life case of Mary Kay Letourneau, a teacher and sex offender. 

Haynes navigates the story with thoughtful exploration, leveraging the acting prowess of Julianne Moore, in the role of the 'naive' woman, and Natalie Portman, embodying an unprincipled actress set to depict her in a film. Their performances strike the right chords, imbuing the film with a rare power and helping to convey an offbeat communication that can leave viewers uneasy. The film's strength, beyond the emotional complexity of its content, lies in its unpredictable trajectory. 

This provocative and controversial psychodrama skates on the edge of madness, unfolding methodically under Haynes’ compelling direction. While there's room for further suspense exploration, the film remains disarming in certain moments. It provokes a significant moral introspection that refuses to leave anyone indifferent. Ultimately, the audience is left with the sensation that there is much more to uncover - something distorted and concealed beneath the apparent restraint of inscrutable emotions.

Napoleon (2023)

Direction: Ridley Scott
Country: USA 

Ridley Scott's Napoleon attempts to capture both the epic military achievements and personal relationships of one of history's most powerful figures, starring Joaquin Phoenix as the French emperor and Vanessa Kirby as Empress Josephine. Known for his prowess in historical dramas, Scott's latest endeavor falls short in grasping the complexity of Napoleon's rise and fall.

The film delves into the events that shaped Napoleon's trajectory, offering a reductive, almost anecdotal vision of his life. While the rough combat scenes stand out as the film's most attractive aspect - the bloody battles against the Russians are potentiated by gloomy undertones and Martin Phipps’ tenebrous score - the overall narrative comes across as disjointed and superficial. 

Even cinematically rewarding in terms of carefully framed shots (the evocative cinematography is by Dariusz Wolski), what we experience is lifelessness. Phoenix's portrayal of Napoleon oscillates between bravery and vulnerability, mirroring the film's own conflicted nature. The lack of a personal perspective also prevents the film from delving into something bolder. 

To make matters worse, Phoenix and Kirby have no chemistry, and the film's energy fizzles out before reaching its conclusion. Abel Gance successfully tackled Napoleon's story in 1927, but Scott's adaptation is another missed opportunity to explore the complexities of France's most significant military commander and historical ruler.

Jeanne du Barry (2023)

Direction: Maiwenn
Country: USA 

Jeanne du Barry, a historical fresco directed, starred, and co-produced by Maiwenn (Polisse, 2011; Mon Roi, 2015), struggles to generate excitement. She shoots the over-the-top costumes and the exuberant Palace of Versailles with a sharp eye, however, the film is totally forgettable. 

The narrative follows Jeanne Vaubernier (Maiwenn), a modest woman with aspirations of social ascent, as she becomes the mistress and favorite of King Louis XV (Johnny Depp). The scandalous romance might have shocked Versailles, but here fails to break free from the constraints of a tightly constricted period drama, resulting in a muddled storytelling experience. Sadly, the potential for vast dramatic possibilities is stifled by a squared and monotonous narrative. 

With predictable plot contours, even the envy and gossip, expected in the French courts, are played too safe. Maiwenn manages to transform the manners and behaviors of the time into effective humor, but the film suffers from a disinterested, passionless performance by Depp, which contributes to the film's plodding pace. This way, the audiences are deprived from the engagement needed to appreciate its historical context.
The various parts of Jeanne du Barry are too uneven to form a decent whole, while the elegiac finale brings even more tedium.