The Crime is Mine (2023)

Direction: François Ozon
Country: France

In François Ozon’s latest film, The Crime is Mine, the narrative follows Madeleine Verdier (Nadia Tereszkiewicz), a struggling young actress accused of murdering a renowned producer who had sexually assaulted her during an interview. Defended in court by her best friend and roommate, the unemployed lawyer Pauline (Rebecca Marder), they initially bask in fame until the iconic silent cinema actress, Odette Chaumette (a scene-stealing performance by Isabelle Huppert), claims responsibility for the crime.

Ozon, infusing the jazzy vibes of the 1930s, adapts a play from that era, creating a whimsical, feminist period farce filled with droll humor and a touch of charm. The film takes a lighthearted approach to murder, capturing the era's spirit through an abundance of color and a joyful atmosphere conveyed in briskly-paced, effortlessly chaotic scenes.

This stylized fusion of theater and cinema, infused with social satire, sarcasm, plenty of lies, and a blend of wacky and goofy moments, explores the burlesque side of screwball comedies. Drawing inspiration from the works of Ernst Lubitsch, Frank Capra, and Sacha Guitry, Ozon mounts the film with a refreshingly old-fashioned flair that doesn't come off as an ironic throwback or shameless nostalgia pandering. The production design is lavish and detailed, complemented by outstanding supporting performances from Fabrice Luchini and André Dussollier.

Less brilliant than 8 Women (2002), The Crime is Mine is performed with an impressive suppression of passion, but never losing sight of more serious aspects akin to today’s world. The elements may feel familiar, even hokum, but Ozon approaches the material with enthusiasm. The film ultimately rewards those seeking a light, feel-good piece of entertainment. 

The Holdovers (2023)

Direction: Alexander Payne
Country: USA

Alexander Payne makes a triumphant return with The Holdovers, a heartwarming comedy-drama set in 1970 that showcases his affectionate style of filmmaking. The film, written by David Hemingson and inspired by his personal experiences, marks the second collaboration with actor Paul Giamatti, known for their previous hit Sideways (2004).

The story unfolds at the prestigious Barton Academy, a private high school for boys, during Christmas break. As three lonely souls - the sarcastic and alcohol-fueled classics teacher Paul Dunham (Giamatti), smart troublemaker Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), and the bereaved cafeteria worker Mary Lamb (Da'Vine Joy Randolph) - find themselves in an unexpected bond. The film skillfully juggles dramatic and comedic elements, creating a distinctive tone. However, this is not a particularly new palette for Payne.

Painful past occurrences reflect behaviors and postures in this refreshing drama with an obvious finale and a couple of sticky moments. Having said that, The Holdovers doesn’t beg to be liked, and the chemistry among the main cast members enhances the overall experience, making it feel like a Christmas treat. 

The story, guided by Payne’s becalmed direction and elevated by Giamatti’s outstanding performance, explores the complexities of growing up emotionally - not without sacrifice - and the factors impelling us to find the strength to move forward. Abrasive at the surface but warm in its fleeting moments of reflection, the film muses and liberates rather than demands or confines. This year’s feel-good winner bubbles with humor and positive change as Payne, transforming an intelligent cerebral script into a captivating film, showcases his storytelling prowess and the power of well-executed, character-driven narratives.