Direction: Erroll Morris
Country: USA
After reading Separated: Inside an American Tragedy by journalist Jacob Soboroff, acclaimed documentarian Erroll Morris (The Thin Blue Line, 1988; The Fog of War, 2003) was compelled to adapt it into a film. The documentary tackles the Trump administration’s ‘zero tolerance’ immigration policy that led to the traumatic separation of migrant parents and children. The resulting film is informative but not particularly engaging, blending interviews with an arguably unnecessary fictionalized depiction of a Guatemalan mother and son’s border crossing, played by Gabriela Cartol and Diego Armando Lara Lagunes.
Soboroff is featured in the film as well as former major figures at the Office of Refugee Resettlement, Cptn. Jonathan White and Scott Lloyd. White’s assertive critique contrasts starkly with Lloyd’s visible discomfort, underscoring the policy’s damaging impact. Due to extended media coverage, most of the details feel overly familiar, and yet it effectively captures the policy’s inhumane implications, serving as a sobering reminder of the need for accountability.
Separated is cleanly arrayed but feels somewhat timid as a terrifying wake-up call that makes us want a better America. Though not groundbreaking, this political documentary tells us we all need to demand more from our politicians, advocating for a more compassionate solution.
